PART
I: Ireland, the Silicon Isle by Niall
McKay
For the last 20 years, Silicon Valley companies have colonized
Ireland. Now, the Irish are returning the favor by coming to Silicon
Valley to plant high-tech startups.
On
Tuesday, Ireland's minister for international trade, Tom Kitt,
opened the "Startup Factory" in Campbell in the heart of Silicon
Valley. Here, Enterprise Ireland, the Irish trade organization,
will help newly established Irish high-tech companies launch their
US operations.
"There are over 600 Irish-owned software companies and every year
there are 50-60 new startups," Kitt told Wired News. "The Irish
government wants to help these companies get established in the
US market."
Ireland,
like Israel, is fertile ground for technology. Ireland's success
in attracting US high-tech companies -- such as Seagate Technology,
Intel, Microsoft, and Sun Microsystems -- earned it the title
of the Silicon Isle. With a population of only 3.5 million, the
country is now the second-largest exporter of software in the
world after the United States.
What's
more, the Irish tech worker has learned a thing or two about entrepreneurship
from the likes of Intel and Microsoft. Ireland now has a bevy
of home-grown tech shops.
These
companies, like their US counterparts, are experiencing explosive
growth rates. For example, software vendor Iona
Technologies reported revenues of US$48.6 million in 1997,
and expects this figure to grow by 69 percent in 1998. Software
encryption and security company Baltimore
Technologies has grown sales from $150,000 to over $10 million
in two years. And new Irish companies such as Internet security
vendor Trintech and smart-card
vendor Card Services International
are poised to take off.
But
to succeed long term, these companies need to be tapped into the
US market, the largest for high-tech products. In addition, capital
is easier to obtain from US investors than from European ones.
"The
message was very clear to us. If we were to grow our company,
we needed to establish a US presence," said Ed Ryan, vice president
of marketing for Clockworks
International, a company that produces international versions
of software for the likes of Lotus, Symantec, and Disney Interactive.
Ireland,
of course, hasn't been an overnight tech success. While the Irish
recognized 20 years ago that they needed to focus on brains instead
of brawn for economic growth, the government was too eager to
appease international investors.
In
1982, a young consultant named Ira Magaziner -- later to become
the White House technology advisor -- was commissioned by the
Irish government to conduct a survey of the country's competitiveness
in the international marketplace.
Magaziner
produced the "Telesis Report (1)", which harshly
criticized the Irish government for spending too much money attracting
foreign companies and investing too little in home-grown concerns.
As a result, multinationals were taking government grants to set
up their Irish operations, staying 10 years for tax incentives,
and pulling out as soon as the pot was empty.
"The
Irish government's industrial policy needed to change," said Magaziner.
"The country had to support indigenous Irish industry rather than
handing out money to foreign companies who were too willing to
take the money and run."
Ireland was also too dependent on England for its trade, Magaziner
said. But times have changed.
"In a couple of years, the Irish government followed all our recommendations,"
Magaziner said. "I am very impressed with the country's willingness
to enter into the information age."
Times are changing for the Irish tech industry, as well. One clear
sign of this is how salaries have improved for the Irish tech
worker. A software developer with three to five years experience
can earn between US$50,000 to $80,000 -– small potatoes
to Silicon Valley, but good money in a low-wage economy.
Irish companies are also becoming savvy enought to set up US offices
and even list their stock on the Nasdaq, as Iona and Computer
Based Training Systems have done.
Just like their Silicon Valley counterparts, Irish tech companies
are having trouble finding enough qualified workers. To combat
this, the Irish government is working to free up its labor laws
so that Irish companies can hire foreign nationals.
"We have realized that companies, especially high-tech companies,
need to be able to freely move their employees around their organizations,"
Kitt said. "So we are trying to facilitate this."
In fact, Baltimore Technology needed to go outside the European
Union to find top-level developers.
"In the last two months we have employed American, Australian,
and Indian developers and technical sales personnel," said Paddy
Holahan, Baltimore's vice president for business development.
Magaziner, for one, is impressed by Ireland's progress.
"Since the early 1980s, Ireland has come up from a poor nation
to the European standard," he said. "If it can grow its own business
then I believe it will become a wealthy nation."
(1)
The Telesis Report
This report, known as the Telesis Report, contained information
so devastating that publication was delayed for over a year. A
few of the main points were:
Only about 30% of the jobs announced by the IDA ever actually
materialised.
Jobs created by foreign industries at great public expense failed
to make up for jobs being lost in traditional Irish industries,
so that despite continued large-scale emigration unemployment
continued to rise.
It had been expected that the multinationals would use Irish firms
as suppliers and sub-contractors. This had not happened, in fact
they imported their raw materials and exported their products
and the country got only the rather low wages of their employees.
The foreign firms did not engage in research and development work
in Ireland, despite inducements to do so.
The report was the subject of lengthy but inconclusive public
debate. On item three, the multinationals made the reasonable
response that they had found native Irish firms incapable of working
to the standards required by a modern enterprise.
PART
II- Yes, but what about top-class research in Music Technology
and SONIC ARTS? (coming soon)
|